# Can you record the police in Pakistan?

> Start with the Constitution: freedom of speech and of the press, and the right to information, with limits that must be reasonable and set by law. The Supreme Court has asked why police do not film their own searches and arrests, and a court can allow a video as evidence. The law draws two lines: do not obstruct an officer, and do not post someone's video to harass them.

- Topic: Criminal law
- Court: Supreme Court of Pakistan
- Citation: Criminal Petition No. 1192 of 2023
- The myth: "Can you record the police, or is that a crime?" Verdict: Two lines: don't obstruct the officer, and don't post it to harass.
- Watch: https://failegal.site/media/can-you-record-police-pakistan (video https://failegal.site/media/can-you-record-police-pakistan/reel.mp4, 1:42)
- Published by FAI Legal on 2026-11-20

A follower asked us how to defend the right to record government officials and the police. People film at checkpoints and on the street, and often wonder whether they may. This page answers with what the law says, line by line.

We read Articles 19 and 19A of the Constitution, Article 164 of the Qanun-e-Shahadat, section 186 of the Penal Code, section 24 of the Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act 2016 and Article 156 of the Police Order 2002 in FAI's Statute Search, and three Supreme Court judgments in full: an order of 22 November 2023 on police recording searches and arrests, a 2017 judgment on a video of an official asking for a bribe, and a 2021 judgment on footage without a forensic check. Names are withheld.

## Key points

- Article 19 of the Constitution protects freedom of speech and expression and freedom of the press, and Article 19A the right to information on matters of public importance; limits must be reasonable and imposed by law.
- The Supreme Court (22 November 2023) said it could not understand why police do not record or photograph searches, seizures and arrests: a recording would be useful evidence and may prevent false allegations (paras 5 and 6).
- A court may allow evidence that has become available because of modern devices (Qanun-e-Shahadat Article 164); in 2017 the Supreme Court watched a video of an official asking a passenger for a bribe, and the penalty against him stayed.
- Two lines: obstructing a public servant can mean up to a year, a fine up to Rs 50,000, or both (PPC s.186(1)); posting a person's video without consent to harass or threaten them, in a way that harms, can mean up to three years, a fine up to Rs 10 lakh, or both (PECA s.24).
- A police officer who vexatiously and unnecessarily seizes your property can face up to five years and a fine (Police Order 2002 Article 156(b)). Keep the original file: without a forensic check, footage cannot be the legal basis for acting against someone (Supreme Court, 2021).

## Can you record the police in Pakistan?

Start with the Constitution. Article 19 gives every citizen the right to freedom of speech and expression, and says there shall be freedom of the press, "subject to any reasonable restrictions imposed by law" on the grounds it lists, such as the security of Pakistan, public order, decency or morality, contempt of court, or an offence. Article 19A gives every citizen the right to have access to information in all matters of public importance, again subject to regulation and reasonable restrictions imposed by law.

This page does not claim that recording is allowed everywhere or in every situation: some places and some situations have their own rules. What it sets out is what the law and the Supreme Court say about video of officials at work, and the two lines the law draws.

## What did the Supreme Court say about police and video?

In a bail case decided on 22 November 2023 (Criminal Petition No. 1192 of 2023), a man arrested in a charas case at a public park said the case was a counterblast to his complaint against some police officials. His lawyer pointed out that in daylight, at a popular park, the only witnesses were policemen, and none of them made a video or took a photograph (para 3). The Court granted bail as a case of further inquiry.

The Court then said it could not understand why the police and the Anti-Narcotics Force "do not record or photograph when search, seizure and/or arrest is made" (para 5). A recording would be useful evidence of the arrest and the seizure, and "may also prevent false allegations being levelled against" the police (para 6). It sent the order to the police chiefs of every province and Islamabad to consider amending the rules to ensure video recordings and photographs whenever possible (para 9).

## Is video evidence admissible in court in Pakistan?

It can be. Article 164 of the Qanun-e-Shahadat 1984 says that in such cases as the court considers appropriate, it may allow to be produced any evidence that has become available because of modern devices or techniques. The 2023 order adds that Article 165 of the Qanun-e-Shahadat overrides all other laws (para 5).

In a 2017 judgment (Civil Petition No. 2749 of 2016, decided 14 June 2017), a video of an official at an airport asking a passenger for money to let his bag through unchecked had been put on social media, and the department retired him compulsorily. The Supreme Court had the video and the CCTV footage played in court, watched the clip again in chambers, found that the sound matched his lip movements with no sign of a voiceover or dubbing, and refused him leave to appeal, so the penalty stayed (paras 9 and 11).

## Does a video need a forensic check?

Courts look at whether a video is genuine. In a 2021 judgment (Civil Petition No. 1033 of 2020, heard 26 April 2021), a department had punished an official on CCTV footage alone, without sending it to a forensic laboratory. The Supreme Court said that "in the absence of any forensic report qua the authenticity of the CCTV footage, the same cannot be considered a legal basis for proceeding against a person", because editing and doctoring are now easy (para 5).

So keep the original file, uncut and unedited, and keep a copy. If the video matters to a case, a lawyer can ask for it to be examined.

## What is obstructing a public servant?

Section 186(1) of the Pakistan Penal Code punishes whoever voluntarily obstructs any public servant in the discharge of his public functions: imprisonment of either description which may extend to one year, a fine which may extend to fifty thousand rupees, or both. Section 186(2) separately punishes hampering, misleading or defeating an investigation, inquiry or prosecution, or issuing a false report, with up to three years.

If you record, do it from where you stand: do not block the officer, hold him back or stop him doing his work.

## Can you post a police video online?

Think before you post. Section 24 of the Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act 2016 makes it cyber stalking, with the intent to coerce, intimidate or harass any person, to take a photograph or make a video of any person and display or distribute it without his consent in a manner that harms a person. The punishment is imprisonment up to three years, a fine up to one million rupees (ten lakh), or both; up to five years or ten million rupees if the victim is a minor.

Keep the original for a court or a complaint, rather than posting it to shame someone.

## Can police take your phone?

Article 156 of the Police Order 2002 punishes a police officer who, among other things, "vexatiously and unnecessarily seizes the property of any person" (clause (b)), or vexatiously and unnecessarily detains, searches or arrests any person (clause (c)): imprisonment which may extend to five years, and a fine.

If your phone is taken, stay calm, note the officer's name, number and the time, and speak to a lawyer about a complaint. Khyber Pakhtunkhwa has its own Police Act of 2017, which FAI does not hold yet; check the law of your province.

## Ask FAI Legal

Don't go by what you hear: read the law yourself. FAI Legal is a website: search the Constitution, the Penal Code and the Supreme Court's judgments, and ask your question in plain words. failegal.site

## The case at a glance

- **Facts:** A man arrested in a charas case at a public park said the case was a counterblast to his complaint against some police officials. His lawyer pointed out that in daylight, at a popular park, the only witnesses were policemen, and none made a video or took a photograph.
- **The question:** Should the man get bail, and why do police not record searches, seizures and arrests?
- **What the Court held:** Bail was granted as a case of further inquiry. The Court said it could not understand why police and the Anti-Narcotics Force do not record or photograph searches, seizures and arrests, and sent the order to every province's police chief to consider rules for video recordings.
- **Why:** Article 164 of the Qanun-e-Shahadat permits evidence from modern devices and Article 165 overrides other laws; police witnesses carry phones with cameras; a recording would be useful evidence and may also prevent false allegations against the police (paras 5 to 9).
- **Limits:** The order is about police recording their own searches and arrests in narcotics cases. It does not decide whether a citizen may record the police.

## In the Court’s words

> "If the police and ANF were to use their mobile phone cameras to record and/or take photographs of the search, seizure and arrest, it would be useful evidence to establish the presence of the accused at the crime scene" (Criminal Petition No. 1192 of 2023, para 6)

> "They may also consider whether they want to amend the ANF/Police rules to ensure making video recordings/ taking photographs whenever possible" (Criminal Petition No. 1192 of 2023, para 9)

## The law it relies on

- **Constitution of Pakistan, Article 19:** Freedom of speech and expression, and freedom of the press, subject to reasonable restrictions imposed by law on the grounds it lists.
- **Constitution of Pakistan, Article 19A:** The right to have access to information in all matters of public importance, subject to regulation and reasonable restrictions imposed by law.
- **Qanun-e-Shahadat Order 1984, Article 164:** In such cases as the court considers appropriate, it may allow evidence that has become available because of modern devices or techniques.
- **Pakistan Penal Code, Section 186:** Voluntarily obstructing a public servant in his public functions: up to one year, a fine up to fifty thousand rupees, or both; sub-section (2): hampering an investigation or a false report, up to three years.
- **Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act 2016, Section 24:** Cyber stalking: with intent to coerce, intimidate or harass, showing or sharing a person's photo or video without consent in a manner that harms; up to three years, a fine up to one million rupees, or both.
- **Police Order 2002, Article 156:** A police officer who vexatiously and unnecessarily seizes property, or detains, searches or arrests a person: up to five years and a fine.

## What this does not mean

- It does not mean you may record anywhere: some places and situations have their own rules, and this page makes no claim about them.
- It does not mean the Supreme Court ruled on citizens recording the police: its 2023 order was about police recording their own searches, seizures and arrests.
- It does not mean any video proves a case: the Supreme Court refused to rely on CCTV footage that had no forensic check (heard 26 April 2021, para 5).
- It does not mean you may follow, block or argue with an officer to get the shot: obstructing a public servant is an offence (PPC s.186(1)).

## Questions people ask

### Can you record the police in Pakistan?

Pakistan's Constitution protects freedom of speech and of the press (Article 19) and the right to information on matters of public importance (Article 19A), with reasonable limits set by law. The Supreme Court has asked why police do not record their own searches and arrests. What the law punishes is obstructing an officer (PPC s.186) and posting a person's video to harass them (PECA s.24).

### Is recording police a crime in Pakistan?

The sections that come close are about obstructing an officer at work (PPC s.186(1): up to one year, a fine up to Rs 50,000, or both) and posting a person's photo or video without consent to harass or threaten them (PECA s.24: up to three years, a fine up to Rs 10 lakh, or both). Stay clear of both.

### Is video evidence admissible in court in Pakistan?

A court may allow evidence from modern devices (Qanun-e-Shahadat Article 164). Courts check that it is genuine: in 2021 the Supreme Court said CCTV footage with no forensic report could not be the legal basis for proceeding against a person.

### Can police take your phone for recording?

A police officer who vexatiously and unnecessarily seizes a person's property can be punished with up to five years and a fine (Police Order 2002 Article 156(b)). Note the officer's name and number, and speak to a lawyer.

### What did the Supreme Court say about police and video?

On 22 November 2023 it said it could not understand why police do not record or photograph searches, seizures and arrests, as a recording would be useful evidence and may prevent false allegations, and asked every province's police chief to consider rules for it.

### Should I post the video online?

Think first. Posting a person's video without consent to coerce, intimidate or harass them, in a way that harms them, is cyber stalking under PECA s.24. Keep the original file for a court or a complaint.

## Sources

- A v. The State (names withheld), Criminal Petition No. 1192 of 2023, Supreme Court of Pakistan, 22 November 2023. Bail granted as a case of further inquiry; the Court could not understand why police and the Anti-Narcotics Force do not record or photograph searches, seizures and arrests, as a recording would be useful evidence and may prevent false allegations, and sent the order to every province's police chief to consider rules for it. (read in full in FAI Judgment Search)
- A v. B and others (names withheld), Civil Petition No. 2749 of 2016, Supreme Court of Pakistan, 14 June 2017. A video of an official asking a passenger for a bribe: the Court had it played in court, watched it in chambers, found no voiceover or dubbing, and refused leave, so the penalty stayed. (read in full in FAI Judgment Search)
- A v. B (names withheld), Civil Petition No. 1033 of 2020, Supreme Court of Pakistan, heard 26 April 2021. CCTV footage never sent for a forensic check could not be the legal basis for proceeding against an official; the tribunal's order setting the penalties aside stood. (read in full in FAI Judgment Search)
- Constitution, Qanun-e-Shahadat, Penal Code, PECA 2016, Police Order 2002, Arts. 19 and 19A; Art. 164; s.186; s.24; Art. 156 (text checked in FAI Statute Search, 20 November 2026)

## What the reel says

Can you record the police, or is that a crime? You asked (@waheed.xd), here is what the law says.

Start with the Constitution: Article 19 protects freedom of speech and of the press, and Article 19A the right to information on matters of public importance; limits must be reasonable and set by law.

The Supreme Court (22 November 2023) asked why police don't film their own searches and arrests: a recording would be useful evidence and can help prevent false allegations. A court can allow a video as evidence (Qanun-e-Shahadat, Article 164); in 2017 the Supreme Court watched a video of an official asking a passenger for a bribe, and the penalty stayed.

But two lines: don't block the officer (up to a year in jail, a fine up to Rs 50,000, or both, PPC s.186), and don't post it to harass or threaten anyone (up to three years, a fine up to Rs 10 lakh, or both, PECA s.24). If an officer seizes your phone for no reason, to harass you: up to five years and a fine (Police Order, Article 156). Keep the original file, uncut: footage with no forensic check can't be the basis to act against anyone (Supreme Court, 2021).

Did you know a phone video can count in court? Yes or no?

---

Educational legal information, not legal advice. Every case turns on its own facts. Speak to a lawyer about your own case. Last checked: 20 November 2026. Review status: Pending advocate review.

English: https://failegal.site/media/can-you-record-police-pakistan · Urdu: https://failegal.site/media/ur/can-you-record-police-pakistan

FAI Media is part of FAI Legal (https://failegal.site), research on Pakistani statutes and judgments. Free to watch and read.
